Follow
Share

My mother passed away in 2015. My father decided in 2016 to sell his home and move down by me. There were no available places at the time for him. So, we decided to help out and have him move in with us until he could get his own place. That was over 7 years ago. Every time I bring it up to him, he has some excuse. He is fully capable of taking care of himself. He drives just fine. In fact now and then he will go visit relatives 4 to 5 hours away. He does woodworking and shoots archery. I am thinking he just doesn't want to live alone. But, him living with us has become such a strain on us.

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
You talk to him honestly and directly, without apology, “dad, I’m glad we could help you out but it’s time we separated households and each loved on our own again. I’ll be glad to help in your search for a new place. This isn’t negotiable, we love you, but it’s simply time” Isn’t an honest talk better than simmering resentment?
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

He sold his home and decided to move near you? So he had money that he ended up paying Capital Gains tax on by stalling 7 years to buy another place?

You and husband need to sit him down and remind him the original agreement was short term, that 7 years is long enough, no more excuses, he needs to find his own place, and we'll help you move. You aren't going to hear any more excuses, you've been nice enough for long enough.

He is probably loving you cooking and cleaning, for starters. He gets to avoid a mortgage, paying homeowners insurance, property taxes...He doesn't have to maintain a home, which is expensive! He avoids grocery shopping, cooking, dishes, cleaning bathrooms, you name it. He gets a room in a nice home with no real responsibilities. He doesn't have to pay utility bills, either. He gets to goof off at your home and have his time alone, while you both work all day.

He's got money from the sale of the other house. He's had enough time to get over his wife's death. I can't imagine what excuses he has left! He'll have to buy some furniture and a TV, but he's got the money. He should have been able to save up plenty staying with you 7 years.

You helped him out at a hard time, so don't feel guilty. You both want your privacy back, period. It was not your life plan as a married couple to have Dad live with you so long! Tell him you are now looking for places for him DAILY, since the longer he waits, prices go up. He doesn't have to BUY a place, he can rent one. Make a daily "search" the new thing for 2024. Stay strong, don't cave!
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Your father does not want to live alone. He has replaced his wife with you . Honestly tell him that he needs his own place, move out date within 3 months . Show him some independent living places so he can get meals and housekeeping or condos for seniors , but he will not be provided with meals or housekeeping at a condo. Independent living would have activities and could find a woman to fawn over him .

He’s a squatter , you would not allow any other person to stay this long .
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
waytomisery Feb 6, 2024
I want to add , when Dad moves out , he does his own cooking , cleaning , laundry , shopping etc , or he hires someone to do it or he goes to Independent living where he gets housekeeping and meals .
You do not become his door dash, cook , personal shopper , laundress or his housekeeper .
(6)
Report
You speak to him honestly and forthrightly. Which apparently you haven't been doing, as it sounds as though he doesn't even have a care contract nor shared living costs with you. That's unacceptable.
Meanwhile you have now made your home his residence. If he battles you you will need an eviction attorney.

Do sit down together, come to a plan, then sit with father and tell him you no longer wish him to live with you, and that you will assist him in finding housing in so far as you are able. Give him a time limit. Be ready to see an attorney if push must come to shove.

There is no substitute for honesty. Lack of it has you where you have landed after 7 years of apparently no shared cost of living. What a shame. I wish you the very best.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Have him tour a couple of ALF's. I am amazed at the services that the one MIL is going into has.

IDK what his feelings are about that--but I can tell you one thing: a healthy man in one of these places? He'll be the darling for all the old ladies. I'm sure the ratio of men to women is like 1/5--I didn't ask, but I also didn't see ANY men and a LOT of women.

Not trying to pimp him out, but he will have plenty of things to do and none of the bother of upkeep, meals, activities, etc. MIL's place even lets you keep your car, if you can still safely drive. It's not a locked down place--so the residents who choose, go places with family & friends. Those who don't have the option of going with the ALF 'family' or just hanging out at the facility.

Being honest with him that he's causing stress in your home would hopefully not hurt his feelings. Some people can do the multigenerational co-living--honestly? Most can't.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

If he's "fully capable of taking care of himself," let him know this OFTEN.
He can get a condo with garage for his woodworking tools. He may need a maid every month, and he can take a cooking class, or subscribe to Hello Fresh.

Or ask those relatives he visits if he can come live with THEM?

Think about this...When Dad was with Mom as a happy couple (before he lost her), did they let other family members move in with them and stay for years? Probably not. Why they were a happy couple!

I see so many couples (in their 50-60s) here are dealing with their stubborn senior parents and stressed out. These stressed out couples need to ask themselves if their elderly parents (back in their middle age years) ever sacrificed their retirement years and took in their own elderly parents? Usually these stubborn, entitled elders never did any prior caregiving for their own elderly parents, nor let them move in.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

One way might be to do some research yourself on options, and then present him with a choice. A bit like the way you deal with dementia – not ‘what do you want’, but ‘do you want x or y’. Perhaps find three Independent Living set ups, with the option for greater care levels later. Say someone (us?) has suggested it, because you make friends more easily if you move sooner. Take him for visits and let him decide which is best. Get him involved in what he likes best, with the firm assumption that he is leaving. It’s not as brutal as ‘Dad you have to get out’, but it gets to the same place.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

RCW,


I love what Dawn has said! Read those wise words again. Especially, where she says that dad didn’t allow others to live in his home.

You don’t have to allow to have your dad live with you anymore. At this point in time it sounds like he is capable of living on his own. If he wants company he can look into senior housing. They offer many activities that he could become involved in.

Wishing you and your family well.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Not sure why everyone is recommending IL or AL. It sounds like he just needs a regular apartment.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Feb 6, 2024
This is true. There are apartments that are geared towards seniors who don’t need supervision. He would be able to make friends there and be active with other tenants.
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
Your question was ‘how do I talk to my father’. My first post was not to start with a talk, start with some visits and ‘which do you prefer’. I’d now add on Dawn’s comment “We didn’t plan to have you live with us so long". Keep the talk about him, not about you and why 'you are throwing him out'.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
waytomisery Feb 6, 2024
I agree . OP does not need to defend herself. The father is an 83 year old failure to launch kid . He needs to get his own place whether it be an apartment , condo , or IL if he prefers to be waited on for meals and housekeeping .
(1)
Report
See All Answers
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter